Punk Lawyer

PunkLawyer wrote:There are a number of stories told in a number of professional milieus, That tell a joke about how the difference between heaven and hell is a matter of staffing. The one I remember best was something along the lines of the happiest man story. The happiest man has a French cook, English, policeman, Arabic poets and German mechanics and a Chinese wife. Now I haven't got it exactly right because the unhappiest man has an English cook, German police, Arab mechanics and an American wife. Please find as many similar stories of this type as you can.

• The Happiest Man in the World has an English country house, a Chinese cook, a Japanese wife, and an American salary.
• The Unhappiest Man in the World has a Japanese house, an English cook, an American wife, and a Chinese salary.

• Heaven is where:
  • The cooks are French
  • The police are British
  • The mechanics are German
  • The lovers are Italian
  • And everything is organized by the Swiss.
• Hell is where:
  • The cooks are British
  • The police are German
  • The mechanics are French
  • The lovers are Swiss
  • And everything is organized by the Italians.

• In Heaven, your car has:
  • German engineering
  • Italian styling
  • British interiors (wood and leather)
  • Japanese reliability
  • And an American price tag.
• In Hell, your car has:
  • British engineering (specifically Lucas electronics)
  • Japanese styling (circa 1985)
  • American interiors (cheap plastic)
  • Italian reliability
  • And a German price tag.

• In Heaven:
  • Product is designed by Apple
  • Engineering is run by Google
  • Logistics are handled by Amazon
  • Sales are driven by Oracle
  • And HR is run by Patagonia.
• In Hell:
  • Product is designed by Oracle
  • Engineering is run by Patagonia
  • Logistics are handled by Apple
  • Sales are driven by Google
  • And HR is run by Amazon.

An engineer dies and is accidentally sent to Hell. Dissatisfied with the working conditions, he immediately gets to work—designing air conditioning, installing flush toilets, and building escalators.

A few months later, God calls Satan to check in and finds out Hell is now a comfortable resort. Realizing the clerical error, God demands, "Send that engineer back up here immediately, or I'll sue!"

Satan laughs and replies, "Yeah, right. Where are you going to get a lawyer?"

A man dies and is told he is going to Hell, though as a citizen of the world, he gets to choose which country's Hell he wants to spend eternity in.

He visits the German Hell, where a resident explains: "First they put you in a vat of boiling oil, then they whip you for two hours, then you eat hot coals." He checks the American Hell and the Japanese Hell—the exact same regimen.

Finally, he walks past the Italian Hell (in some versions, Greek or Russian), where there is a massive line out the door. He asks someone in line why it's so popular when the torture is identical. The guy replies: "Well, on paper it's the same—but half the time they're out of oil, the guy with the whip is on a three-hour lunch break, and the coals are on backorder."

Charles Carreon wrote:What is the historical origin and earliest known print appearance of the 'In Heaven the cooks are French' joke?

Gemini wrote:The "European Heaven and Hell" joke is a classic piece of modern folklore with no single confirmed author. While it is frequently misattributed on the internet to figures like Art Buchwald, Peter Ustinov, or George Carlin (who famously recited it on The Tonight Show), folklorists and quotation researchers treat it as an anonymous aphorism that evolved out of post–World War II European travel and Cold War–era cultural stereotypes.

Historical Origin and Context
The joke relies on a neat structural inversion of mid-20th-century Western European national caricatures:

• Heaven: The police are British (polite and unarmed), the cooks are French (haute cuisine), the mechanics are German (precision engineering), the lovers are Italian (passionate), and it is all organized by the Swiss (punctual and efficient).
• Hell: The cooks are British (bland food), the police are German (authoritarian—a direct nod to WWII/Gestapo tropes), the mechanics are French (temperamental), the lovers are Swiss (stiff/unromantic), and it is all organized by the Italians (chaotic bureaucracy).

Because it specifically references mechanics (reflecting the post-war boom in European auto tourism) and relies on the contrast between friendly British "bobbies" and authoritarian German police, humor scholars such as Christie Davies (Ethnic Humor Around the World) situate its emergence in the 1950s to 1970s, circulating heavily among diplomats, expatriates, and business travelers in Europe before crossing into mainstream English-language print.

Earliest Print Appearances
Because the joke circulated orally and on novelty postcards, cocktail napkins, and souvenir T-shirts across Europe for years before being formally indexed, pinpointing an absolute "first" print date is notoriously difficult, though clear milestones exist:

1. 1970s–1980s European Ephemera & Expat Circles: Before appearing in bound books, the text was widely printed on tourist postcards and posters sold in Brussels, Luxembourg, and London during the rise of the European Economic Community (EEC) in the late 1970s and early 1980s.
2. Mid-to-Late 1980s Periodicals and Anthologies: The joke began appearing regularly in English-language newspapers, humor columns, and corporate cross-cultural training manuals by the mid-1980s. For example, it appears in British club newsletters by September 1988 (Veteran Athletics No. 7) and was a staple of early cross-cultural business communication texts by the end of the decade (such as Gary P. Ferraro’s The Cultural Dimension of International Business, first published in 1990).
3. 1990s Quotation Dictionaries: By the early 1990s, it was formally canonized as an anonymous proverb in major reference works, including the Oxford Dictionary of Modern Quotations and Brewer's Dictionary of Phrase and Fable, which list its origin simply as "Anonymous" or "Traditional."

False Attributions

• Art Buchwald: Often credited in online quote databases, likely because Buchwald was an American humorist living in Paris who frequently wrote about Franco-American and European cultural differences in the 1950s and 1960s. However, no verified column of his contains the original formulation.
• George Carlin: Carlin helped popularize the joke in North America by performing it in his stand-up and late-night television appearances, though he explicitly introduced it as an old, anonymous joke rather than his own material.